“…and ye shall be as gods.” (Satan) – Genesis 3:5
By University of Nottingham, 6/23/2017
I was looking through my twitter timeline on 12 June, when I came cross a tweet by Dietram Scheufele which said “’bend nature to our will.’ #CRISPR frame in new #Doudna book might resonate differently across audiences […] #scicomm”. The tweet made reference to an article by Sharon Begley in STAT News about Jennifer Doudna’s new book, co-authored with Samuel Sternberg, A Crack in Creation: The New Power to Control Evolution, in which they reportedly write that it “won’t be long before CRISPR allows us to bend nature to our will”. I became curious about this new book and its grand claim.
The book: publicity and reactions
On 16 June, Jennifer Doudna, a pioneer in a new way of modifying or ‘editing’ genes called CRISPR Cas9, came to the UK to talk with Adam Rutherford about her new book at a Hay Festival event held at the Royal Society. CRISPR Cas9 is based on exploiting the way that bacteria snip out parts of an invading virus’s DNA “and keep a bit of it behind to help them recognise and defend against the virus next time it attack”. Scientists, like Doudna, have “adapted this system so that it could be used in other cells from animals, including mice and humans”.
The blurb for the event (which I could unfortunately not attend) says: “’A Crack In Creation’ also asks us to consider what our new-found power means: how do we enjoy its unprecedented benefits while avoiding its equally unprecedented dangers? As Doudna argues, every member of our species is implicated in the answers to these questions. Somehow we must consider and act together. The future of humankind – and of all life on Earth – is at stake. This book is an essential guide to the path that now lies ahead.” (From what I can ascertain, unicorns were not mentioned at the event)
It appears that Jennifer Doudna wants to stimulate public debate about this new technique for genetic manipulation or gene or genome editing. This is a great example of what some call ‘upstream’ engagement with an emerging technology by one of its founders. This is also an example of what people would now call responsible innovation. As one reviewer of her book, Peter Forbes, says: ”It’s always difficult when something like this [gene editing] happens to sort the hope from the hype, but anticipation is now intense. Doudna does, though, sound many notes of caution.”
Another review of Doudna’s book by Nathaniel Comfort, is a little bit more critical and says: “Rather than guiding us through the ethical thickets of precision genetic engineering, or providing a candid, warts-and-all look at one of the great scientists of our time, the book mainly polishes her ‘good scientist’ image and rationalizes the unfettered self-direction of human evolution, within liberal bounds of safety, efficacy and individual choice.” I became more and more curious.
Unicorns, dragons and flying pigs
Let’s get back to the article mentioned in the tweet by Scheufele. After reading that tweet, I read the article by Sharon Begley for STAT news entitled, intriguingly, “CRISPR pioneer Doudna envisions a world of woolly mammoths and unicorns”. We are told that: “This Doudna doesn’t hold back. We are ‘on the cusp of a new age in genetic engineering and biological mastery,’ she and Sternberg write, dangling the prospect of ‘life-changing treatments’ and ‘lifesaving cures.’ She says she is ‘not kidding’ that CRISPR could bring about ‘woolly mammoths, winged lizards, and unicorns. … It won’t be long before CRISPR allows us to bend nature to our will.’”
Wow, I thought, these are some claims. I also asked myself whether this is really how one sorts “the hope from the hype”? And I wondered whether and how the unicorns were picked up by other news articles reporting on the book (they were not mentioned in the Forbes and the Comfort reviews).
I found an article for CBC radio that notes: “Imagine a world where genetic diseases can be edited and cured, where pigs can be ‘humanized’ to use their organs for transplants in people — and where we might even run into unicorns or winged dragons.”
Here lizards have turned into dragons. Interestingly, dragons had been discussed in the context of gene editing, but one of the co-authors of the book had intimated that they would not be created: “Dr Sam Sternberg – formerly of the University of California’s Doudna Lab, which pioneered work with CRISPR-CAS9 – said […] he is not hopeful genetic engineers could ever cross the Rubicon to create dragons.” (BBC interview, 3 January, 2016)
The other article appeared in The Daily Beast and was entitled “New DNA tech creating unicorns and curing cancer for real”. Unicorns and dragons are here joined by yet another mythical creature: “Scientists say that CRISPR-Cas9 may soon allow them to perform miraculous fixes to eliminate or alter mutations that cause everything from some cancers to Parkinson’s disease. More whimsically, the technology could be used to create, say, a unicorn, or a pig with wings; though it’s unlikely they could make swine fly.” Lizards have turned into flying pigs….
Unicorns in context
I was now thoroughly hooked; I ordered the paperback edition of the book; and read it. It is a breezy and enjoyable account of the whirl-wind in which Jennifer Doudna found herself after the discovery of CRISPR Cas9, a new way to target and edit genes.
This rather personal account of excitement and collaborations is interspersed with cautious reflections on the social and ethical implications of CRISPR, but also with references to mastery (“over the code of life”, p. 113; “to rewrite the very molecules of life anyway we wish”, p. 119) and control (chapter 4 is called “Command and Control” echoing the subtitle of the book: “The New Power to Control Evolution”). Control and caution jostle with each other.
I also found the unicorns. They make their appearance in chapter 5 entitled “The CRISPR menagerie” (paperback, p. 117). Here is the quote that got some people so excited: “Within a few decades, we might well have genetically engineered pigs that can serve as human organ donors – but we could also have wooly mammoths, winged lizards and unicorns. No I am not kidding.”
The next paragraph goes on to say: “It amazes me to realize that we are on the cusp of a new era in the history of life on earth – an age in which humans exercise an unprecedented level of control over the genetic composition of the species that co-inhabit our planet. I won’t be long before CRISPR allows us to bend nature to our will in the way that humans have dreamed of since pre-history”. We are back to the tweet that set me off in chase of unicorns.
I couple of pages later the book’s sometimes breakneck foray into a new CRISPR world populated by novel plants and animals, including unicorns, is somewhat slowed down by a note of caution: “We have a responsibility to consider the ramifications in advance and to engage in a global, public, and inclusive conversation about how to best harness gene editing in the natural world, before it’s too late.” This is a call for ‘Responsible Research and Innovation’ or RRI.
Unicorns and responsible language use
A Crack in Creation has, it seems, three aims: firstly and mostly to convey the excitement of CRISPR; secondly to point out emerging risks (especially with relation to germline editing); and thirdly to stimulate public debate. My question is: are unicorns the right way to go about stimulating this debate?
I have written quite a few posts about CRISPR, some more about responsible innovation, and some others where I try to include responsible language use in the RRI agenda. I have also written an article with Carmen McLeod entitled “The dilemma of raising awareness responsibly”. The book certainly exposes this dilemma.
Viewed from the perspective of RRI and responsible language use, A Crack in Creation might therefore not only stimulate public debate about CRISPR; it might also stimulate debate about responsible language use. As we have seen, unicorns grab public and media attention; but are they good examples of responsible language use, especially since they can easily morph into flying pigs?
Master builders
This episode in the history of gene editing and public engagement reminded me of the early days of nanotechnology, where excitement mingled with concern and public discussion. At the time (around 2003/2004), a former colleague of mine, José López wrote about the trope of the master builder which he saw running through some of the early nanotech discourses, a trope that is also commonly used in science fiction. In an interview he pointed out:
“’Looking at science fiction helps us understand how we talk about nanotechnology. Science fiction usually relies on revolutionary technology or a major event to define how society works. Nanotechnology gets talked about like that—some argue that it will change everything,’ López says. This world-changing technology or event is called a novum—time travel and parallel universes are classic examples. Science fiction then typically includes a master builder who interacts with the novum and drives the story line. ‘With this mindset, we perceive nanotechnology—and the scientists driving it, the master builders— as a way to reconstruct a new world,’ López says. ‘We’re speaking the language of hubris to think we can control the future in this way. We have to remember that nanotechnology is still in its infancy.’”
This is perhaps something we should reflect on in all the excitement and promise surrounding gene editing today, as it has implications for science, society and science communication.
Join The Fight Today!
Camelot Daily is one of a few independent news agencies willing to expose the ‘synagogue of Satan’s (S.O.S.) assault on civilization. More people than ever are receiving our message. However, S.O.S. controlled monopolies such as Google, Facebook, Twitter etc. “96% of the World’s Media,” have eviscerated our advertising revenues, using government subsidized unconstitutional, Maoist like, schizophrenic censorship. It’s noteworthy to mention that Israeli scientists discovered 99.9% of Ashkenazi Jews have a 40% chance of developing schizophrenia, certainly not the type of people you want creating policies that effect the whole world and yet social media giant Facebook, 800lb search engine gorilla Google and the web’s most ubiquitous discussion network Disqus are all controlled by individuals who may be schizophrenic. The Camelot team, humbly ask our readers from around the world to support us by sharing our articles, supporting our advertisers, purchasing one of our liberty themed t-shirts at: TreasonTees.com and by donating to Camelot at PayPal.Me/silvanusmedia or to donate bitcoin, copy and paste the following Bitcoin Wallet Address: mqGTT5X4BrVTdhbhxX93ojcaumSSXXFHSr Thank You!
Camelot Daily’s independent, S.O.S. exposing news journalism requires a great deal of time and money. However, we care about those who are awake and opposed to the S.O.S.’s goal of exterminating all human life on earth. If everyone who reads and likes our reporting, help us, Camelot Daily will become more effective at defeating the S.O.S. For as little as $5, you can support Camelot – and it only takes a minute. Thank you.
Follow us on Gab
Follow us on Twitter
Subscribe to our Blog
Subscribe to our BitChute
Subscribe to our YouTube Channel
[…] Jewish Chemist Samuel Sternberg’s Plan To “Bend Nature To Our Will” (read more) […]
[…] Jewish Chemist Samuel Sternberg’s Plan To “Bend Nature To Our Will” (read more) […]
[…] Jewish Chemist Samuel Sternberg’s Plan To “Bend Nature To Our Will” (read more) […]
[…] Jewish Chemist Samuel Sternberg’s Plan To “Bend Nature To Our Will” (read more) […]
[…] Jewish Chemist Samuel Sternberg’s Plan To “Bend Nature To Our Will” (read more) […]
[…] Jewish Chemist Samuel Sternberg’s Plan To “Bend Nature To Our Will” (read more) […]
[…] Jewish Chemist Samuel Sternberg’s Plan To “Bend Nature To Our Will” (read more) […]
[…] Jewish Chemist Samuel Sternberg’s Plan To “Bend Nature To Our Will” (read more) […]
[…] Jewish Chemist Samuel Sternberg’s Plan To “Bend Nature To Our Will” (read more) […]
[…] Jewish Chemist Samuel Sternberg’s Plan To “Bend Nature To Our Will” (read more) […]
otc cialis
cialis generic name
ed meds online without doctor prescription
Jewish Chemist Samuel Sternberg's Plan To "Bend Nature To Our Will" – Camelot Daily
Viagra best buy
Buy cheap viagra
Best price for generic viagra
How to get viagra
cost of cialis
is there a generic cialis available?
buy naltrexone
Jewish Chemist Samuel Sternberg's Plan To "Bend Nature To Our Will" – Camelot Daily
viagra cialis
cialis savings card
viagra suppliers
Jewish Chemist Samuel Sternberg's Plan To "Bend Nature To Our Will" – Camelot Daily
viagra for sale canadian
Jewish Chemist Samuel Sternberg's Plan To "Bend Nature To Our Will" – Camelot Daily
viagra generic
cheap viagra
new ed pills
online ed pills
cheap erectile dysfunction pills online
erectile dysfunction medications
ed pills otc
buy ed pills
chloroquine cost
Jewish Chemist Samuel Sternberg's Plan To "Bend Nature To Our Will" – Camelot Daily
order cialis
buy generic cialis
buy hydroxychloroquine online
Jewish Chemist Samuel Sternberg's Plan To "Bend Nature To Our Will" – Camelot Daily
canada pharmacy
cvs pharmacy
canadian online pharmacy
walmart pharmacy
Cialis in usa
Real cialis online
levitra 10mg
levitra cost
levitra generic
levitra 10mg
levitra 20 mg
levitra 10mg
play for real online casino games
wind creek casino online games
generic viagra india
sildenafil 100
empire casino online
pala casino online
Cialis 20mg Price beergaumma [url=https://acialisd.com/#]Cialis[/url] entich What Is Priligy miseDefMeeni generic cialis for sale CoallKab Acheter Priligy Usa
legitimate online slots for money
online casinos for usa players
cialis prices
liquid tadalafil
pay day loans
installment loans
cash payday
no credit check loans
cialis buy
cialis to buy
cheapest 100 viagra uk
Jewish Chemist Samuel Sternberg's Plan To "Bend Nature To Our Will" – Camelot Daily
new cialis
new cialis
20 cialis
generic cialis
cialis buy
20 cialis
generic for cialis
20 cialis
price check 50mg viagra
Jewish Chemist Samuel Sternberg's Plan To "Bend Nature To Our Will" – Camelot Daily
buy cialis
20 cialis
gambling casino
casinos online
online slots for real money
online casino usa real money
cheap viagra online
viagra cost
Title
[…]always a huge fan of linking to bloggers that I adore but don’t get a whole lot of link like from[…]
viagra online canada
viagra price
sildenafil
WALCOME
viagra samples
WALCOME
how to buy viagra online
WALCOME
viagra cost
WALCOME
tadalafil online canadian pharmacy
cialis tadalafil
can i buy viagra online
WALCOME
generic cialis 20mg
purchase cialis
viagra without a doctor prescription
WALCOME
sildenafil vs tadalafil
generic cialis tadalafil
real money casino online
real money casino online
where can i buy viagra from in uk
WALCOME
casino slot games
free casino games
buy pink viagra uk
WALCOME
can i really buy viagra online
WALCOME
http://www.jueriy.com
Jewish Chemist Samuel Sternberg's Plan To "Bend Nature To Our Will" – Camelot Daily
cialis generic name
Jewish Chemist Samuel Sternberg's Plan To "Bend Nature To Our Will" – Camelot Daily
where to buy cheap viagra online with prescription
WALCOME
viagra sale
WALCOME
rxtrustpharm.com
WALCOME
rxtrust pharm
WALCOME
widespread instead of the next whiff, solitary can about the. [url=https://ciamedusa.com/#]cialis[/url] Vmldxf tomlre cialis buying online buy cialis online cheap
autocad 2020 software price 2D 3D CAD software site to [url=http://buyautocad.design/#]buy autocad[/url] 2020 design software tutorial. ux design software 2020 [url=https://www.seoservices4sale.com/secrets-to-improve-the-user-experience-on-your-website/#comment-96963]office suite for mac air a[/url] 4dd6719 new software 2020 mobile engeeeneringu#$sssaunnplus , office software license. top 10 software for pc 2020, office software on chromebook free office software pc office software suites free. astrology 2020 software free download waec 2020 software download, logo design software 2020.
rx trust pharm
WALCOME
RxTrustPharm
WALCOME
Title
[…]usually posts some very intriguing stuff like this. If you are new to this site[…]
Title
[…]check below, are some entirely unrelated internet websites to ours, on the other hand, they’re most trustworthy sources that we use[…]
Title
[…]we came across a cool web page that you just may well get pleasure from. Take a look when you want[…]
Title
[…]that could be the finish of this write-up. Here you will uncover some internet sites that we believe you’ll value, just click the links over[…]
Title
[…]we came across a cool internet site that you just might appreciate. Take a appear in the event you want[…]
Title
[…]we prefer to honor many other online internet sites around the net, even when they aren’t linked to us, by linking to them. Beneath are some webpages really worth checking out[…]
Title
[…]just beneath, are many totally not related sites to ours, nevertheless, they may be surely really worth going over[…]
Canadian pharmacy viagra
Free viagra sample
cheap viagra pills free shipping
WALCOME
Title
[…]below you will find the link to some web-sites that we think you should visit[…]
when should you take viagra
WALCOME
Title
[…]please go to the web pages we follow, including this one particular, because it represents our picks from the web[…]
Title
[…]here are some hyperlinks to web sites that we link to mainly because we believe they are worth visiting[…]
Title
[…]we like to honor quite a few other web websites on the internet, even if they aren’t linked to us, by linking to them. Underneath are some webpages worth checking out[…]
Title
[…]here are some links to internet sites that we link to due to the fact we consider they’re worth visiting[…]
Title
[…]one of our guests lately proposed the following website[…]
Title
[…]Every the moment inside a while we select blogs that we study. Listed beneath are the latest websites that we pick out […]
Title
[…]check below, are some totally unrelated web-sites to ours, having said that, they are most trustworthy sources that we use[…]
Title
[…]we came across a cool web page that you just could delight in. Take a look if you want[…]
Title
[…]here are some hyperlinks to internet sites that we link to simply because we feel they may be worth visiting[…]
Title
[…]Here is a great Weblog You may Come across Interesting that we Encourage You[…]
Title
[…]very couple of internet sites that transpire to be comprehensive below, from our point of view are undoubtedly nicely really worth checking out[…]
Title
[…]please check out the web sites we adhere to, like this one particular, because it represents our picks through the web[…]
Title
[…]one of our guests recently advised the following website[…]
Title
[…]usually posts some extremely exciting stuff like this. If you are new to this site[…]
Title
[…]always a significant fan of linking to bloggers that I enjoy but really don’t get a great deal of link enjoy from[…]
Title
[…]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine several unrelated data, nonetheless actually really worth taking a look, whoa did a single understand about Mid East has got additional problerms also […]
Title
[…]please pay a visit to the web sites we follow, like this one, as it represents our picks in the web[…]
Title
[…]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine several unrelated data, nonetheless seriously worth taking a search, whoa did one discover about Mid East has got extra problerms as well […]
Title
[…]although web-sites we backlink to beneath are considerably not related to ours, we feel they may be in fact worth a go by means of, so have a look[…]
Title
[…]Every the moment inside a although we choose blogs that we study. Listed below would be the most up-to-date internet sites that we decide on […]
Title
[…]we like to honor several other world-wide-web web pages around the internet, even when they aren’t linked to us, by linking to them. Under are some webpages worth checking out[…]
Title
[…]The information mentioned in the write-up are some of the top out there […]
Title
[…]very couple of internet websites that occur to be detailed beneath, from our point of view are undoubtedly properly really worth checking out[…]